The Best Non-Toxic Self Tanners for a Natural Glow

Summer’s almost here, and if you’re anything like me, you want that golden, end-of-summer glow now. But most store-bought self tanners? They’re packed with questionable chemicals that are anything but skin-friendly. Just because you want a tan doesn’t mean you should risk your health.

The good news? There are clean, non-toxic self tanners that actually work and give you that natural, streak-free glow without the orange drama. I’ll share my favorites (with links!) and help you avoid the worst offenders hiding in your bottle.

5 Toxic Ingredients in Self Tanners to Avoid at All Costs

Pro tip: Flip the label on your current tanner. You might be surprised what’s hiding in there.

1. Alcohol (Ethanol)

Used to dissolve dyes fast, but it dries out your skin like crazy. Hello flaking, irritation, and redness. Not the vibe for a natural-looking tan.

2. Mineral Oil

Although it may make skin feel soft at first, it’s a pore-clogging, petroleum-based filler that can cause breakouts and leave a greasy shine.

3. Fragrance

Sounds harmless, but “fragrance” is code for a mystery mix of hormone-disrupting chemicals. If a product smells amazing but doesn’t list the ingredients, it’s probably too good to be clean.

4. Formaldehyde

Yep, the same stuff used to preserve lab specimens. It helps deepen color fast, but is a known carcinogen and hormone disruptor. Even in small doses, no thanks.

5. Parabens

Preservatives that mess with your hormones by mimicking estrogen. Linked to breast cancer and fertility issues. Watch for anything ending in “-paraben” on the label.

Best Clean & Non-Toxic Self-Tanners on Amazon

Beauty by Earth Self Tanner Spray

I LOVE how easy this one is to work with. I give it a quick mist after my shower routine, let it dry while I brush my teeth or do my skincare, and by the next day I have a really natural-looking glow with no streaks. This one is great for a fast tan, while it does not last as long as a lotion or mousse it is good for those lazy days when you still want to feel good!

Beauty by Earth Self Tanning Drops for Face

I love how easy it is to control the color with these drops, just mix a few into your moisturizer for a subtle glow and add more if you want a deeper tan. It blends right into my routine without any extra steps. Just remember to wash your hands after using it!

Beauty by Earth Face Tanner Serum

If the drops feel a little too customizable or fussy some days, I reach for this one instead as it’s more of a set-it-and-forget-it option. It gives a super natural, even glow and doubles as skincare with the hyaluronic acid, so my skin feels hydrated too. I like using this one when I want something simple and consistent without having to mix anything. Just apply like a regular serum and you’re good!

Beauty by Earth Bronzing Face Tanner Spray Mist

This mist is my go-to when i want zero effort, just a few spritzes and done. It dries super fast, doesn’t break me out, and gives a really natural glow over time. Compared to the drops or serum, this one’s the easiest if I’m in a rush or don’t feel like touching my face. Perfect for busy mornings or layering over skincare without thinking too hard.

Beauty by Earth Self Tanner for Face

This one is a nice option if you want something that builds gradually and feels more like part of your skincare routine. It’s super moisturizing and has a nice scent, which makes it easy to use daily. Compared to the drops or spray, this one gives you the most hydration and feels the most like a regular face cream, great if you want to simplify your routine but still keep a glow.

Beauty by Earth Self Tanner Mousse

This is what I grab when I want a deeper, more noticeable tan, it gives that “just got back from vacation” look. It goes one really smoothly with a mitt, dries quickly, and lasts way longer than the sprays or serums. If you want something bold and long-lasting, this one’s the way to go.

What Type of Non-Toxic Self Tanner is Best for You?

Not sure where to start? Here’s a quick breakdown of the different types of non-toxic self-tanners so you can pick what works best for your skin, schedule, and glow goals.

Self-Tanning Mousse (aka the fast-dry foam)

If you want something quick and easy, mousse is the way to go. It’s a light, fluffy foam that dries fast and blends super evenly, with less risk of streaks or orange patches. Perfect if you’re in a rush or don’t want to be sticky all day.

Natural Self-Tanning Lotion

Lotions are your go-to if you love a moisturizing moment. These go on like a regular body cream, but gradually build color over a few hours. Most clean versions are loaded with nourishing ingredients like shea butter or coconut oil, so you get hydration and a glow. Great if you want something subtle and low-maintenance that fades evenly. And that you don’t have to wash off (usually).

Self-Tanner Spray

Sprays cover big areas fast and can be super convenient, especially for hard-to-reach spots like your back. Just keep in mind: sprays can fade quicker than lotions or mousses, and you’ll usually get better results using a mitt to blend it out.

Self-Tanning Drops

These are perfect if you want full control over your glow. Self-tanning drops mix right into your favorite face or body moisturizer, so you can customize how deep your tan gets just by adding more or fewer drops. They’re great for beginners or anyone who wants a super natural-looking tan without switching up their skincare routine. Bonus: Many non-toxic formulas are packed with skin-loving ingredients too.

Top Tips for a Streak-Free, Non-Toxic Self Tan

Exfoliate & Shave

Always, always exfoliate and shave before, you want to be as smooth as possible, make sure to also use a non-toxic exfoliator and shaving cream!

Moisturize dry areas

To avoid patchiness, lightly moisturize knees, elbows, ankles, hands, and feet. I love using the Attitude Body Lotion for this, super clean and lightweight.

Reapply as Needed

Lotion and oil-based tanners may need more frequent reapplication. Most don’t require rinsing before layering, but always check the directions on your product.

Closing Thoughts

Ready to ditch the toxic stuff and glow with confidence? These non-toxic self tanners are absolute game changers, giving you that sunkissed look and peace of mind.

Don’t forget to browse the links below and grab the one that fits your routine best.

Got a fave I didn’t mention? Comment on this post or send me a DM, I love finding new clean beauty wins!